TOUCHSTONES DISCUSSION ARTICLE PUBLISHED IN LEADING EDUCATIONAL JOURNAL
“As students read and converse about great texts, they learn to think deeply, speak thoughtfully, and respect multiple points of view,” wrote Touchstones Discussion Teacher Cynthia Barry in an article published in the March issue of Educational Leadership, a leading national journal.
Ms. Barry based her article on her experience leading Touchstones Discussions at St. Martin’s-in-the-Field. The program is now in its sixth year at our school. All St. Martin’s middle schoolers engage in weekly discussion classes based on brief essays by authors such as Plato, Aristotle, Euclid, Francis Bacon, St. Thomas Aquinas, Buddha, Thomas Jefferson, Isaac Newton, Immanuel Kant, Mary Shelley, and Richard Feynman. They also read folktales from China, Persia, Nigeria, and Japan. The seminar-style discussion group gives students a forum for conversation, an alternative to the unmediated forces of Twittering, Facebooking, and YouTubing. It also gives them early training in discussion skills they’ll use throughout high school, college, and their working lives.
In response to article, Dr. Joanne Olson, associate professor of science education at the Center for Excellence in Science and Mathematics Education at Iowa State University, wrote in an email to Ms. Barry:
“Thank you so much for your superb article in this month’s issue Educational Leadership. I found it very refreshing to read an article from this important perspective that seems to be getting lost in the hype about technology and the accompanying false promises of how all these gizmos are going to save schooling. Your efforts to keep standards high and engage students in that which makes us human is central to a great education… We’re dumbing down ourselves in our quest for sound bites and entertainment. Your well-crafted article shows that not only is this level of intellectual engagement possible, but it is necessary for our students. Keep up the good work and keep fighting the good fight.”
A copy of the article, “From Great Texts to Great Thinking,” will be going home to all middle school parents. As always, parents are invited to participate in our Touchstones Discussions. No reading in advance is required; all participants simply apply their reasoned thought to the text and genuinely pursue their inquiries in the conversation. Call Ms. Barry at extension 31, so she can pull an extra chair for you into the circle.
SIX ADVANCE TO STATE-LEVEL JUDGING IN LETTERS ABOUT LITERATURE COMPETITION
Six students advanced to state-level judging in the Letters about Literature contest, the nation’s premiere writing and reading competition, sponsored by the Library of Congress and the Maryland Humanities Council. Each year students across the nation write a letter to the author of a book that affected them deeply and changed them in some significant way. The program encourages readers to think about impact a book has on them.
Our fourth graders entered at Level I (grades 4, 5, and 6), and our seventh graders competed at Level II (grades 7, 8, and 9). Congratulations to Isabelle Carney, Victoria Decker, Corbett Glick, and Julia Mathews in 4th grade, and to Casey Glick and Virginia Ritinski in 7th grade. In Maryland, 1,829 Letters were received; nationally, 69,000. To reach this level of judging, a student’s Letter has to have outshone hundreds of letters, in the opinion of the judges. Letters are chosen on the basis of a student’s ability to express his or her thoughts and to articulate the ineffable connection between author and reader.
Fourth and 7th grade students worked hard on their Letters this past fall in Library class with Ms. Barry. All who engage actively in reading, thinking, and writing deserve a round of applause. Students composed strong leads, expressed sincere thoughts, included telling details, shaped the flow of their writing, constructed strong sentences with vivid verbs and varied structure, and built to a memorable and poignant conclusion.
Our workshops were focused. Students learned the importance of revising their work, exercising the ability to objectively appraise their own writing, and finding the right words to express their intent. Students had the experience of working collaborative with each other and an editor. Last year, we had a Maryland 1st place winner and National honor winner in Cameron Fitzgerald, who won $1,000 for the library of his choice. That library was St. Martin’s.
Everyone is a winner who has a relationship with the written word. Reading helps us understand the complexities, challenges, and rewards of life. A special cheer is in order for Isabelle, Victoria, Corbett, Julia, Casey, and Virginia.